QUOTE(ShaggSet @ Oct 8 2006, 12:45 AM)

I think the best SoCal High School team vs. the best Midwest High School team would be roughly the same match-up as the best SoCal club team vs. the best Midwest Club Team. Probably a similar outcome. However, I think that the level of domination of SoCal over Midwest would be even greater in high school compared to club just because in Orange County there are so many good clubs with good players in each age group in a pretty small area which creates some really good high school teams; ie. Mater Dei, Mira Costa, Corona Del Mar, and a bunch more.
You got it right. I am a staunch Midwest fan, but the degree of
separation between top Cali h.s. teams and top Midwest
h.s. v-b teams is far greater than it is in club. The sheer number
of club players, and high school teams where a high percentage
of the team is in club, is much higher in SoCal than anywhere
in the Midwest. I don't think a Wis high school team could beat
a Wis 16's club, much less a Wis 17 - 18 or a SoCal 16-18
When the number of Midwest clubs with 18's teams shrinks
and the talent coalesces, the gap with SoCal closes.
North Shore Milwaukee has finished 5th-3rd-2nd-2nd
at JO 18's the last four years, and STL Hi-P and
various Chicago clubs have been in the final 8 a
lot also. All occasionally medal in the younger ages,
but more so at 18's.